The original St. Louis Real Estate Blog, est 2004 with Darin "Sid" Cameron, CRS.
Understand the St. Louis housing and real estate market better. Sid is a licensed real estate broker in Missouri.
The St Louis Agent Team of RE/MAX Properties West
 | For Agents | Forum | Bookmark Site
Subscribe to RSS Feeds - Click Here!
Bookmark and Share
Chat with an Agent!
Real estate questions?
Want to see a home?
 Click for Live Chat or
Call: (314) 598-4040
 Email this Article! Email this article d Discuss this article d Printer friendly page with resizable text
 New Bill to Keep Banks out of Real Estate
By: Darin "Sid" Cameron, CRS
Fri, Jan 7th, 2005 1:23 am

This week Congress introduced a bill titled, "Community Choice in Real Estate Act," to permanently ban banking conglomerates from entering real estate brokerage or property management. This is because some of the larger banking conglomerates have requested permission from the Federal Reserve Board to sell and manage real estate. Pretty much every major organization in the real estate industry is backing the bill against banks in real estate.

My take: To be honest, the name of the bill sounded a bit Orwellian to me.

My first thought is, “how does prohibiting competition (i.e. the banks) give me the consumer a greater choice?” It’s easy to assume that real estate industry giants are just trying to keep a potential competitive threat out of their business in much the same way the local mom and pop retailers will do everything possible to keep new Wal-Marts and Home Depots from being built next to their stores.

Then I started thinking about this a bit more. If Bank of America, CitiBank, and the rest of the national banks were allowed into the industry, what would really happen and who would benefit the most from it? Would it give us more or less competition? What would it mean to the average Joe who just wants to buy or sell a home?

That’s when I realized it really would eliminate competition and hurt the average consumer. Why? Because a Bank of America wouldn’t just go rent a small office space with a couple of employees downtown and try to build their business from the ground up- beating the Prudential’s, Coldwell Banker’s, and Remax’s of the world on better service. No, a Bank of America would enter the market by throwing out Billions in cash to buy out the largest real estate chain they could land. Heck, they might even buy a couple of them! Isn’t that how they became a bank in St Louis in the first place- buying out one of our local chains?

If this bill were passed, it would undoubtedly start a feeding frenzy of banks buying out real estate companies to capture the largest amount of market share they could capture as quickly as possible. Once the first few deals were done, there would be tremendous pressure on other banks to follow suite. Ironically, the real estate industry giants trying to keep banks out of real estate would probably fare quite nicely selling out their businesses!

Doing a quick Google on the nation’s largest banks, I discovered that the largest, Chase Manhattan, is worth $270 Billion dollars. What I found interesting is that Banker’s Trust, the nations 5th largest bank, is only worth $95 Billion- or roughly 1/3 the size of Chase. There’s a huge drop off once you get past the first four banks (Morgan, the number four bank, is worth $173B or almost twice the size of Banker’s Trust). So which four banks do you think will succeed in buying out the largest real estate companies? What do you think will happen to the Banker’s Trust’s of the world when a Chase or a Bank of America gets 5-6 times their size instead of 2-3 times? You guessed it, another round of bank mergers!

So now we’ve established what will happen- mass acquisition and name changes; fewer banks and real estate companies. But what about the average Joe who just wants to buy or sell a home? Realistically, a change probably wouldn’t change the number of real estate agents on the street. Unlike other industries, agents are basically self-employed- so their numbers are regulated by the supply and demand of sales, not by the large companies looking to get into the business.

But fewer agencies tied to a bank will undoubtedly mean an increase in overall expenses to the consumer. How? By supplying all the services you need to buy a home, the banks would be able to reduce the competition the consumer could get in areas like finance and insurance. Real Estate basically becomes a bank’s way to capture your business in much the same fashion as buying a photocopy machine locks you into buying toner and supplies from the company that made the photocopier.

Although there would be laws prohibiting a bank from “requiring” a home buyer to use only the bank’s services, there could be extreme pressure put on an agents to deliver a portfolio of services to their buyer. Since many consumers rely on their agent to line up financing for them, they could be lulled into higher rates and greater fees. Think about this, since the banks began merging a few years ago, what has happened to free checking, free ATM use, and other formerly free services at your national banks?

However to see the biggest threat to the average Joe from a real estate/banking merger you only have to look at the Savings and Loan crisis from the 1980’s. The Savings and Loans went wild in the real estate industry writing one bad loan after another in an attempt to grab more sales. In the end it cost tax payers Billions to bail them out.

[ Next Article: Cold Weather and Frozen Pipes ]
[ Previous Article: Identity Theft ]

Search this Blog:

Darin 'Sid' Cameron, CRS

Contact Me on Facebook!

 Contact me on LinkedIn!

Follow me on Twitter!
Darin "Sid" Cameron spent 15 years working in the technology industry which in 1998 relocated him to St. Louis. In 2004 he took over web development tasks for Kimberly's real estate team and later became the full-time Marketing and Operations Director in 2005. In 2011 Sid launched two brokerages, The Realty Store, Inc. and Realty Referral Partners, Inc, while continuing to perform marketing and operations for Kimberly's team. Sid holds a real estate broker's license in Missouri, CRS certification and was the first CyberStar in the St. Louis area.
Certified Residential SpecialistCyberStar!
Follow me on Active Rain!

All Blog Articles XML/RSS

Add to My Yahoo!

All Categories
 News  Things to Do  Real Estate Trends  Misc Stuff  Selling a Home  Calendar of Events  Home Repair  Buying a Home  Interest Rates and Financing  Investment Real Estate  Credit Reports and Safety  Our Website and Services  Government and Legislation  Internet Resources  Living in St. Louis  Home Improvement  St Louis Housing Market  Real Estate Statistics  Home Safety  Blogging In General

RE/MAX Properties West
Kimberly Cameron, Team Leader
RE/MAX Properties West Direct: 314 598-4040
16497 Clayton Road Office: 636 532-5900
St. Louis, MO 63011 Fax: 800 573-1985
Email Us Here! Toll Free: 800 573-5276
Equal Housing Opportunity
The St. Louis Agent Team of RE/MAX Properties West